TogetherOff GridTogether Off Grid

Land and place

Homesteading in Montana: Western Montana History and Lessons

In short

Montana's homestead boom began in 1900 and ended in a bust around 1920. So this guide is history, not current law. Records from the Bitterroot and North Fork show what that life took: hard work, stored food, side income, and good neighbors. Before you buy, check today's rules with the county.

By Together Off Grid teamPublished 8 min read

Last reviewed

A couple walk along a split-rail fence toward a log cabin in a Western Montana valley at golden hour.
On this page
  1. Can you still homestead in Montana?
  2. Where is the best place to homestead in Montana?
  3. What did homesteading look like in the Bitterroot?
  4. What was homesteading like on the North Fork of the Flathead?
  5. Is it possible to live off grid in Montana?
  6. Who do you want beside you on a Montana homestead?
  7. Questions people ask

Can you still homestead in Montana?

Keep the timeline close. The Montana Historical Society (opens in a new tab) says Montana's homestead boom began in 1900 and lasted until the bust around 1920. Claiming land meant endless chores, plus the steady work of proving up the claim.

This guide doesn't cover current programs. And if you hear about a state or county program, confirm the rules with the agency that runs it before you plan your life around it.

The rush was big. According to the National Park Service's Homestead National Historical Park, 151,600 homesteads were proved up in Montana (opens in a new tab). Homesteaded land totaled 32,050.480 acres, 34% of the land in the state, which is a hard number to ignore.

The Montana Historical Society credits several causes for that rush. They include Congressional Homestead Acts of 1868, 1877, 1894, 1902, and 1909, along with advances in agricultural technology, railroad marketing, and weather.

Railroads wanted settlers too. The Milwaukee Railroad, the Great Northern, the Northern Pacific and the Burlington Railroad all wanted to attract homesteaders, and so did the state of Montana itself.

Claim size changed over time. Great Plains Quarterly (opens in a new tab) notes that the 1862 Homestead Act set 160-acre plots, and the Enlarged Homestead Act of 1909 doubled that amount. But more acres also meant more work for the same hands.

Where is the best place to homestead in Montana?

No single place is best, and our sources don't rank one. They do show that parts of the state had very different stories. What you want to grow matters. So does how much hard winter you can take, and how far from town you want to live.

Start with central and eastern Montana. In twenty years, from 1900 to 1920, the region went from a sparsely settled province to one peppered with homesteads, new towns, and new counties, says the Montana Historical Society. That is fast change on a working landscape.

You'll meet the term dryland farming in that story. The Society's Hard Times chapter (opens in a new tab) defines it as "agriculture without irrigation in regions of scanty precipitation." In plain terms, water was the daily question.

Then came dry years. During the drought in the late 1910s, Lillian Stephenson recalled, she "couldn't even rake up enough money to buy a postage stamp." She called Montana homestead life "just desolation." Weigh that verdict against any easy dream of off grid partnership.

Western Montana's story started earlier. The National Park Service's registration form for the Whaley Homestead (opens in a new tab) says that after the Original Homestead Act of 1862 was passed, Montana's earliest claims were staked in the western valleys of the state.

If you're weighing the region, start with our Western Montana page. We have no sourced figures for land prices or parcel sizes. Before you build plans around a place, ask local agents what nearby land recently sold for.

What did homesteading look like in the Bitterroot?

Bitterroot farmers sold food early. During the 1860s, says the Whaley Homestead form, farmers from the Bitterroot traded potatoes and other staples at the mining camps of Bannack and Virginia City. And that trade tied valley farms to the camps.

Peter Whaley, an Irish immigrant, settled the Whaley Homestead in 1877. The form says the Whaleys were reportedly not exceptional farmers, and that most farms in the Bitterroot turned out to be marginal. That detail matters when a valley looks easy from a distance.

The family did more than farm. Raising livestock added to the farm income, and the Whaleys also ran a meat market in Stevensville, a sawmill in Florence, and the Stevensville Hotel. Their living came from more than one lane.

Peter built a log house on the homestead in 1879, and by 1885 his improvements included a large, log-framed house that still stands. The homestead sits on what is now the Lee Metcalf Wildlife Refuge near Stevensville.

Our read is simple: good land may not pay every bill by itself. So as you plan your own income, consider the Whaleys' mix of farming and business. Your version might be a trade, remote work or a small business, or any mix that fits the place.

What was homesteading like on the North Fork of the Flathead?

Look north. The National Park Service's North Fork Homesteads brief (opens in a new tab) says Jeremiah McCarthy built the McCarthy Homestead Cabin in 1908, just seven years after the North Fork road was first established.

The registration form for Vance Lodge (opens in a new tab) says settlers claimed about 100 homesteads west of the North Fork river between 1910 and the beginning of World War I. So most of that subsistence homestead development sat along the river, in small meadows and open bottomland.

In 1914 Andy and Ella Vance staked a 160 acre homestead claim near the North Fork of the Flathead River. Ella grew a big garden, and Andy hunted and trapped for food. The form's own verdict is plain: a subsistence existence.

Even the name Polebridge came from neighbors working together. Area homesteaders built a 400' long pole bridge to reach Big Prairie, but it lasted only a season (a short return on all that work). And the county replaced it in 1916.

The North Fork brief also shows how quickly places can disappear. Patricia Bick's 1986 research led to the listing of seven North Fork homesteads in the National Register of Historic Places. But the 1988 Red Bench Fire destroyed three of them.

Beginning in summer 2008, a University of Montana team led by Douglas McDonald inventoried approximately 40 homestead sites in the North Fork. So if remote land up there appeals to you, slow down before you buy. Ask about fire risk and road access, and about how you would get out in an emergency.

Is it possible to live off grid in Montana?

People have long lived on this land with little outside help (the Vances, for example, lived a subsistence existence). But these sources are historical. They don't cover today's rules on building permits, septic systems, wells, water rights, or road access, so ask the county about each one before you buy.

The records are blunt about the labor. The Hard Times chapter says homesteading was hard work and no one was excused. And the chores piled up: breaking sod, building a house, picking rocks, hauling water, plowing, planting, fencing, butchering, milking, and canning.

Some newcomers misread the winters. Danish immigrants Peter and Bertha Josephson Anderson homesteaded near Sidney in 1899. They had anticipated a much milder climate. So they neglected to lay in a sufficient supply of food for their first winter.

Experience mattered too. M. L. Wilson's 1922 study of dryland farming in north-central Montana revealed that only 50.5 percent of 550 homesteaders in the area had previous farming experience. So let that push you to be honest about what you know.

Here's what we'd take from these records:

  • Lay in food for winter early, and plan for harsher weather than you hope for.
  • Practice the basics before you buy, such as hauling water, fencing, butchering and canning.
  • Keep more than one way to earn money, as the Whaleys did.
  • Get to know your neighbors before you need them.

That point has deep roots. According to Great Plains Quarterly, in 1915 Mary Tanner and thirty-two families shared community life at Round Butte, Dawson County, clustered around a school and post office. Neighbors threshed grain and raised barns. And they helped with the crops of neighbors laid up by accident or illness.

Their cooperation went further. And it extended to the creation of a new county, Garfield, in 1919.

Who do you want beside you on a Montana homestead?

The record includes people who worked beside family and people who filed on their own. Ida Hewitt filed her own claim for 320 acres adjoining her brother Wilbur's on the Milk River near Saco, the Montana Historical Society says. And they raised cattle and kept Brown Leghorn chickens.

Bright Watts, a Black homesteader, acquired 154.12 acres in Cascade County, according to the National Park Service. He testified against a desert entry claim that was not improved properly in 1903. And in 1904 he claimed his own homestead.

If you hope to share a homestead life with someone, talk early about the work and the money, and about the land too. Our guide to moving to land as a couple covers what to sort out first. And if you're thinking of buying together, read buying land together before marriage.

Our piece on splitting the work on a homestead can help you start the talk about who does what. And if you're still looking for the right person, how to find a homesteading partner is a good place to begin.

Questions people ask

When did the Montana homestead boom start and end?

The Montana Historical Society says the boom began in 1900. It lasted until the bust around 1920. And according to the society's Hard Times chapter, fewer than one thousand people per year completed patents on homestead land in Montana until 1901 (a small trickle before the rush).

How big were homestead farms in Montana?

Great Plains Quarterly says Montana homesteaders plowed farms that averaged 134 acres in 1901 and 265 acres in 1925. Wheat shows up in the record as well. The Montana Historical Society's Hard Times chapter says it covered 435,000 acres of Montana in 1910, but by 1929 farmers cultivated 4,419,000 acres of it. That is a steep climb in under twenty years.

Does the Whaley Homestead still stand?

Peter Whaley's large, log-framed house, part of his improvements by 1885, still stands, according to the National Park Service's registration form. The homestead sits on what is now the Lee Metcalf Wildlife Refuge near Stevensville. But the form doesn't discuss visits, so check with the refuge before you plan a trip.

Which railroads wanted homesteaders in Montana?

The Montana Historical Society names the Milwaukee Railroad and the Great Northern, then the Northern Pacific and the Burlington Railroad. It also says the state of Montana wanted to draw homesteaders. So the railroads weren't the only ones pushing to fill the land.

Where does the name Polebridge come from?

Area homesteaders built a 400' long pole bridge to reach Big Prairie, and the National Park Service says Polebridge was named for it. But it lasted only a season (not much return on all that building). The county replaced it in 1916.

Sources

Keep reading

All journal guides

Somewhere out there, someone is building the same life